Understanding Workplace Envy: A Guide to Navigating Career Decisions
You know that stinging sensation you get when your coworker gets the promotion that you thought was yours? Or that sinking feeling of doom when you realize that a new hire could take over your role? Most likely, that voice within will tell you: “You’re falling behind.”
However, you may be overlooking an important emotional experience happening simultaneously: envy, which is simply wanting something that someone else has. Due to the stigma and shame attached to this emotion, many tend to suppress it without realizing it. While understandable, this can lead to significant mistakes.
For conscientious high achievers, seeing someone else’s success can prompt questions about one’s own situation. Envy is a universal emotion, and it’s normal to wonder if it’s time to make a significant change, such as seeking a new job or career. Yet, examining your envy first can help you avoid costly career pitfalls.
Beware of ‘Premature Game Switching’
A common reaction to workplace envy among coaching clients is to make a change. While this may feel proactive, it often results in giving up on the current situation too soon, a phenomenon referred to as “premature game switching.” When you see someone getting ahead, you might jump to the conclusion that you can’t achieve your goals in your current role, leading you to opt out and choose a different path.
Taking action feels better than doing nothing, but failing to pause and reflect on your envy means ignoring critical insights.
All negative emotions have what is called “signaling value,” which prompts us to pay attention to what is important. Fear alerts us to danger, grief arises from loss, and envy highlights what we truly desire, helping to avoid “desire confusion.”
In today’s world, savvy advertisers and social media expose us to what philosopher René Girard termed “mimetic desire.” We often want what those around us desire. The scope of envy has expanded, as we can now see many more things that many more people have, which can cloud our judgment.
Envy provides an opportunity to clarify what we genuinely want.
Heed the SIReN
To analyze envy, consider its four key components, summarized as “SIReN.”
First, S stands for “similar target.” According to social psychologist Abraham Tesser’s Self-Evaluation Maintenance model, we tend to compare ourselves to peers who are just ahead of us, leading to envy. This comparison can provide hope, indicating that we are not as far behind as we might think.
Second, I represents “intangible desire.” What we truly seek is not the object itself but the feelings we believe we will experience upon obtaining it. For instance, it may not be the promotion itself, but what it signifies, such as financial security or recognition.
Third, Re denotes “relevant comparison.” We tend to envy in areas that matter to us. If we care about our careers, we are likely to experience career envy, which helps pinpoint what we value and where we may want to focus our energy.
Finally, N signifies “negative emotion.” This unpleasant feeling serves as a gauge. If you can easily dismiss the envy after closing an app, it may not be worth dwelling on. However, if it lingers, it’s worth examining further.
Next, Channel Envy in the Right Direction
Research by social scientists Jens Lange and Jan Crusius indicates two types of envy: benign and malicious. Malicious envy occurs when you fixate on the person who has what you want, while benign envy focuses on your own desires. The Right Reverend Allen Shin, Bishop Suffragan of the Episcopal Diocese of New York, noted that with malicious envy, you relinquish your agency to the person you envy. Conversely, when you concentrate on how to achieve your goals, you maintain your agency.
After analyzing your envy and identifying the intangible desire, the next step is to determine “skill-building microactions.” Ask yourself what small activities you can try to move closer to your goals. For example, if you realize that your desire for a promotion stems from a need for financial security, quitting your job may be a costly mistake. Instead, enhancing your personal finance knowledge could be more beneficial.
Ultimately, when we channel our envy toward meaningful work, nurturing relationships, and serving others, we can enhance our life satisfaction and contribute positively to the world.
Source: Fast Company Work Life