Italy Imposes €805 Million Fine on Meta for Unconsented Access to User Galleries
Meta has been fined €805 million in Italy due to a feature in Facebook for Android that suggests photos and videos from users’ phone galleries for posting. The Garante, Italy’s data protection authority, found that this feature was enabled by default and accessed users’ photos, videos, and related metadata without their explicit consent.
The company has 60 days to disable this feature by default, including for users who have already granted the app access to their galleries, and to request consent separately.
A spokesperson for Meta stated that the fine is “disproportionate” and the company plans to appeal the decision. The app requests gallery access through a single permission that encompasses multiple functions, but the Garante noted that users are not clearly informed that enabling other features also grants access to gallery suggestions.
When fully granted, this permission allows the app to read the entire photo archive on a phone, typically on an ongoing basis. Neither users nor the authority can verify which information is actually utilized.
The authority identified a violation of Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which incorporates the EU’s ePrivacy Directive into Italian law. This regulation considers a phone part of an individual’s private life, necessitating free and informed consent for any access to its stored data.
The Garante’s order requires Meta to:
- Within 60 days, request consent through a separate, specific request for this feature, clearly explaining its purpose, that it accesses the gallery, and how to disable it.
- Within 60 days, ensure the feature is turned off by default, even for users who have already granted permission.
- Within 30 days, report to the authority on the progress made, and within 90 days, on the measures implemented.
If Meta fails to meet the 60-day deadline, the feature cannot be activated for users who have not provided valid consent.
Meta emphasized that the feature only operates after users grant permission on their devices, and they can modify that permission at any time in their settings.
The investigation was initiated following a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection group in Bolzano, which published consumer advice on July 11, 2025, urging users to disable the gallery suggestion settings in the app and review the permissions granted to Facebook.
The investigation did not assess whether gallery content was utilized to train AI models, a claim Meta denies. The authority may also investigate a newer feature launched this year that allows gallery content to be processed in the cloud.
Meta contended that Ireland’s data protection authority should oversee the case, but the Garante dismissed this argument, stating that ePrivacy rules do not provide a one-stop-shop mechanism.
This feature has been available since 2023, and the investigation commenced in July 2025, including a technical analysis by the authority.
The fine represents approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue. In determining the amount, the authority considered the large number of affected users, estimated at 20 million Android users in Italy, and the duration of the breach, which continues for users who have not updated the app.
Other factors influencing the fine included a previous decision against Meta in 2019 and limited cooperation during the investigation. Although changes made by the company after the complaint were taken into account, they were deemed late and applicable only to users who updated the app.
Source: The Hacker News